As a student, the beginning of the semester means budgeting challenges. On top of set expenditures like tuition, student fees, and rent, there are textbook costs. As more publishers move their content online, e-textbooks or physical copies become an important consideration I think about when purchasing materials. This blog post aims to compare and contrast the two formats of textbook and why students may opt for one over the other.
Cost
If you already have a device, digital textbooks are cheaper than brand new physical books. However, there are alternative ways for students to access more affordable physical copies. Not only does UBC Bookstore offer rental options, there are usually second-hand textbooks flowing around in different marketplaces.
Tip: For some disciplines, the UBC library may have the resources you need. Check out their site before buying materials.
Value
Another aspect related to cost is the value of your purchase. Consider how long you would like to keep the book. I have some practical textbooks that are bookshelf worthy. Physical copies are yours if you buy them but many e-textbooks and rental books have expiry dates.
Additionally, while I may keep some textbooks for future usage, most of my books are re-sold to other students. Places like UBC Bookstore, Facebook Marketplace, and Craigslist are helpful when it comes to getting part of my expenses back. Physical textbooks have a much higher re-sell value, especially if you can keep them in pristine condition. On the other hand, e-texts have a very low to no re-sell value as they are often restricted within platforms and rental periods.
Functionality
Function-wise, well, a physical book is a book: you can read, highlight, or write in it but that is pretty much it. A physical copy is limited in functionality, especially for someone who enjoys interactive activities like myself.
Depending on the website or file format, the diversity of tools at your disposal is much greater in a digital copy. My favourite part of e-textbooks is the search function (command + F), especially for key concepts or terms. Beyond a basic pdf, platforms like VitalSource or LaunchPad also offer functionalities such as flashcards, bookmarks, or even quizzes to review your material.
Convenience
Being a psychology student, most of my textbooks are big, heavy, and have 300+ pages. Needless to say, having all my books on a single device is very convenient, especially as a commuting student. The downside of digital textbooks is their reliance on technology. Books do not require internet or power; they provide certain aspects of safety when your electronic device may fail due to technical difficulties.
Something to consider: For open-book in-person exams, some profs do not allow technology so you either have to copy down all your textbook notes or bring in a physical book.
Personal Considerations
At the end of the day, the format needs to be suitable for my learning needs. Having online textbooks means longer screen time and more distractions. Personally, I intake information from a physical book easier than e-text. Also, I love the feeling of holding a book: the texture and aesthetics cannot be replicated by an iPad or computer.
When buying textbooks, there can be many considerations that help you decide what suits you the best. My experience with textbooks is as diverse as my courses, but I cannot cover it all. Share your experiences in the comments below when buying a textbook and your tips on how to save, other students will thank you for it!
Here are some additional links or resources that might interest you as a student on this topic:
- Many lecturers and professors are opting for Open Education, you can learn more about the initiative and its resources here.
- Learn about UBC Senate’s principles on digital textbooks and how it impacts student’s options and learning.
- Check out this article on the reading brain and how it is impacted by digitalization.
